Everything You Need To Know: Best Non-Stick Pan America’s Test Kitchen

Savoury Table is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more.

No meal would be perfect if it weren't cooked with love, talent, and quality cookware! If you already do not own an excellent non-stick pan in your collection, it's time you check out our list!

We have put together a lengthy list of the top 7 best non-stick pans that will make your next meal prep a whole lot easier. It's time you bring your culinary skills to the next level and see why these pans are on our top list!


Top 3 Recommendations

Best Non-Stick Pan America's Test Kitchen 2021

Carote 8 Inch Nonstick Skillet Pan - Best Pick

When you search through Amazon, the Carote non-stick skillet is the best-rated item! Why is that? Let's check out some of its features together so you can get a bigger picture of why this is the best skillet pan with a non-stick coating.

For starters, the Carote skillet pan includes an eco-friendly granite coating. The Carote uses a PFOA-free layer which will not cause any harmful reactions since it's not a chemical pollutant. However, some of the users question its durability. But, let me tell you that Carote nonstick skillets are one of the best high-quality items we have come across.

The skillet pan is easy to clean and maintain for longer use. The body is made out of Diecast, so it's durable and convenient for use.

One of the most outstanding qualities this nonstick skillet has is its suitability to use on gas stoves, induction, halogen stove, or ceramic stove. How amazing is that? We are all about versatility, and that is precisely what the Carote nonstick skillet has to offer.

Many satisfied customers reported that this skillet is best for omelets as it features rolled edges. It will make your cooking a whole lot easier with its curved exterior for those perfect edges.

The skillet pan offers a 12-month guarantee for your sound-mind purchase! This is one of the most affordable skillet pans on the market, but you must remember that the price often justifies its quality.

  • Affordable price
  • Suitable for all stoves
  • Wooden handle
  • Not so durable

Cuisinart 622-30G Chef's Classic Nonstick - Runner Up

They don't call this pan a Chef's Classic nonstick pan for nothing! This is one of the most popular non-stick pans on the market, and we are here to test it out!

The Cuisinart is a relatively heavyweight but well-balanced pan with a wear-resistant construction. This fry pan will last you for a very long time. It's made out of hard-anodized aluminum, which is heavier than stainless steel, so it might take you some time while you get the hang of it.

Moreover, the Chef's Classic nonstick pan includes a tall design with sloped edges that can be amazing for slow-cooked meals but not so much for flipping. Some customers noted that this is not the pan you want if you want to flip a few pancakes or an omelet.

Other than that, it has some of the most impressive qualities, such as a lifetime warranty! Not only does it give you a sound mind, but it will make your money's worth!

A feature that surprised us what that this nonstick pan is suitable for oven-cooked meals and can withstand a 500°F temperature.

Overall, this is one hell of a non-stick pan! It disperses heat evenly and heats up pretty quickly, so if you are always in a rush, this is the pan you want to get!

  • Oven-safe
  • Best for slow-cooked meals
  • Even heat distribution
  • Made out of hard-anodized aluminum
  • Lifetime warranty
  • Nonporous and dense
  • Not suitable for flipping
  • Heavy construction

OXO Good Grips Non-Stick Pro - Best Frying Pan

The Oxo Good Grips non-stick pan is yet another trendy pick among chefs. This is a 12-inch skillet, so if you need plenty of space to fit your meal of choice, this is the perfect skillet for you.

Just as the previous pick, the Oxo Good Grips non-stick skillet is made out of hard-anodized aluminum, which makes sure it delivers an even heat distribution. There is nothing more awful than having to deal with an unreliable pan when you want to get creative in the kitchen.

That's why millions of home cooks trust and appreciate the Oxo pan. Nothing is surprising about it; the only impeccable quality that delivers exquisite results each time.

The Oxo frying pan is delivered to us by the tremendous german manufactory. Now, do you understand why everyone raves about its sturdiness and quality?

The frying pan is made out of a three-layer PFOA-free non-stick coating. Another highly notable feature is the very design of the frying pan.

It features rolled edges that will prevent the dripping of sauces and other liquids. On top of that, the Oxo Good Grips nonstick fry pan includes a heat-resistant riveted stainless steel handle that ensures a comfortable and secure grip.

What will make this 12-inch skillet stay in your household for a long time are the scratch-resistant materials. The pan can withstand high temperatures of 390°F which is outstanding!

  • Best for frying eggs, caramelizing onion
  • Rolled edge design
  • Silicon coated stainless steel handle
  • 12-inch design
  • Can withstand high temperature
  • Dishwasher safe
  • The outside coating is not the best

T-Fal Professional Total Nonstick - Best Fry Pan With a Heat Spot Indicator

Let me tell you; you can never go wrong with a good-old T-Fal nonstick pan! This is a non-stick thermo spot heat indicator pan you will love! It's time you get out your favorite stir-fry recipes, as this is the pan you should pay attention to!

To start, the T-Fal frying pan includes a stainless steel base which will deliver the utmost durability and prolonged use. Thanks to its high-quality base, the pan can reach high temperature evenly, leaving no spots unheated.

But, the fascinating feature is that this nonstick fry pan has a bottom that is suitable for induction cookers! Many struggle to find the best cookware for induction tops, so consider yourself lucky you have stumbled upon this excellent fry pan!

Moreover, the nonstick fry pan comes with a Prometal Pro nonstick design, making the frying pan scratch-resistant and therefore much more durable. On top of that, the pan is dishwasher safe which will save you time on cleaning it.

You can even put the nonstick fry pan in the oven as its high-quality handles can withstand a 400°F temperature. They are coated with silicone which offers a non-slip and secure grip.

We saved the unique feature for the end. The Heat Spot has an innovative thermo technology that tells you if the pan is perfectly heated for your cooking adventure!

  • Suitable for oven use
  • Durable
  • Thermo spot as a heat indicator
  • Stainless steel base
  • Metal utensils can damage the surface

Calphalon 2 Piece Classic Nonstick Frying Pan - Best Skillet for Low-simmer Cooking

Next up, we have the highly popular Calphalon 2-piece nonstick skillets. This is one of the best-selling items in the Caphalon cookware collection, so let's see what so special about it.

This nonstick pan is made out of not one but two layers of PFOA-free non-stick coating, for starters! The doubled design will deliver the best results you can't even imagine!

Moreover, the Caphalon frying pan includes a medium gauge anodized aluminum construction which will offer durable use. As you already know by now, this type of cookware is high-quality, sturdy, and resistant to rust or chipping.

The cooking surface of this anodized aluminum design will prevent the leaking of any harmful chemicals or any other components in acidic foods.

The 10-inch skillet includes cool-to-touch handles that won't cause any accidents in the kitchen. They are designed out of stainless steel, which may add a bit of weight to the pan, but it's nothing you should stress over.

All of their cookware, including this non-stick pan, is oven save! It can withstand a 450°F temperature like a pro!

In this purchase, you will receive a 10-inch pan and an 8-inch one which is ideal if you want to complete your cookware collection on a budget. Plus, the flared edges are optimal for versatile cooking, so you can fry, saute, sear, and more!

  • Includes two pans
  • Stainless steel handle
  • Durable ceramic design
  • Two layers of nonstick coating
  • Even heating
  • Not suitable for metal utensils

Sensarte Nonstick Frying Pan Skillet - Best Omelet Pan

How many are you looking forward to breakfast omelets? I know I do because this Sensarte delivers the perfect omelet every time! There will be no more mess-ups and failed meals now that you have this fry pan by your side. It's time we see how you can use its features to your advantage!

The Sensarte frying pan includes the Swiss-non-stick coating, which is both PFOA-free and safe for cooking food.

If you want a sleek and luxurious-looking nonstick skillet, then this is the one you should get. It features a woodgrain bakelite handle which is both comfortable to use and offers a firm grip. As the handle is made tom heat-resistant materials, it's safe to use in an oven at 302°F.

Furthermore, the nonstick pan is made out of high magnetite conductive base with a stainless steel bottom. This means you can use the pan on all types of stoves, including induction.

Plus, the bottom will make sure it heats up evenly and quickly, so you don't have to wait around for the pan to heat up.

We love that this pan is easy to clean and maintain! To be honest, nobody wants to bitter scrubbing the pan for hours! That's why the Sensarte nonstick pan is made out of casting aluminum which is convenient for maintenance! Just wipe it over with a clean paper towel and minimize the cleaning time afterward.

  • Affordable price
  • Oven-safe
  • Easy to clean and maintain
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Woodgrain handle
  • It does not support metal utensils

Rachael Ray Brights Nonstick Frying Pan - Best Color Selection

Do you tune in every day to watch the magnificent Rachel Ray? Not only does she deliver us the most impressive recipes, but now you know one of her best cooking secrets! Using this non-stick frying pan, of course!

Its durable construction with a hard enamel finish is what will surprise you the most! This is a pan that can take the heat like a true champion. Thanks to the high-quality design, the non-stick skillet pan evenly distributes heat throughout the pan.

With the rubberized handle, you can safely cook your favorite dish without worrying if the heat has caught on to it. Plus, it's a secure grip with a comfortable side which is another plus from us!

Moreover, you can put this skillet in the oven, and the handle can withstand 350°F heat! How amazing is that?

What will entice most of the customers is the wide color selection! The Rachael Ray nonstick frying pan is available in several fun colors so that you can color-coordinate them with the rest of your cookware.

The non-stick surface and the exterior will make the cleaning task of this pan much easier! In most cooking situations, you will only need to wipe down the pan with a paper towel to prepare it for the next meal.

Lastly, the Rachel Ray skillet pan comes with a lifetime warranty so that you can have a sound mind with this purchase.

  • Available in different colors
  • Oven-safe
  • Easy to clean and maintain
  • Lifetime warranty
  • The paint can sometimes wear off

Buyer's Guide - Features You Should Consider

1. Size

Let's talk skillet size first. For most home cooks, a 10-inch pan is a perfect pick. You can fry up dinner for a smaller family, but if you need a bigger cooking surface, we suggest a non-stick 12-inch skillet.

If you are often cooking for just yourself, then a good-old 8-inch pan is perfect.

2. Handle

best non stick pan america's test kitchen

We love when pans include a long handle! It makes preparing food so much more fun and easy when it comes to handling the pan. But, you have to be careful.

If you decide to buy the best skillet with a lightweight handle, it would most likely be made out of plastic. There is an obvious downside to this as this kind of skillet cannot go where it withstands over 400°F.

Even if the skillet has a wooden or stainless steel handle, it's better to go with a heavier option if you want versatility.

3. Material

Non-stick pans are available in several different materials such as cast iron skillet models, aluminum, stainless steel, or Teflon. You have to consider if the material's characteristics as they might not complement your cooking needs.

For instance, aluminum is affordable but not as good at retaining heat. Stainless steel is rather heavy, but it holds and distributes heat evenly. Ceramic will offer an excellent alternative to Teflon, but it does have some the downsides, such as durability.

Tips For Longer Service

If you recently invested in the best non-stick pan, you need to learn how to take care of it properly. Here is some advice on how you can prolong the service of your recent buy.

best non stick pan without teflon
  • Even though you can wipe down the skillet after use, you have to give it a thorough clean. Wash the skillet with water and soap after every use. Do not ever use metal scrubbers that can damage the coating!
  • Do not let the skillet get too hot, especially if it's empty.
  • Place a paper towel or a foam protector on the cooking surface when you want to store the pans. This helps preserve the non-stick coating, especially if you put one skillet on top of the other.
  • Avoid using metal utensils at all costs! They can be extremely rough on the cooking surface, and you can say goodbye to the non-stick coat after that.


What non-stick pan does Gordon Ramsay use?

The well-known chef Gordon Ramsay uses the ScanPans! The chef uses these same pans because they require pretty little to no oil at all. If you are looking for ultimate quality and perfection when cooking, these pans are an unbeatable choice.

Their cookware is made from PFOA-free non-stick coating, which delivers healthy and environmentally friendly food preparations.

What is the best non-stick frying pan to buy?

The best non-stick frying pan is the OXO Good Grips Non-Stick Pro. The OXO pans come from a family of brands trusted by millions of professional and home cooks! This nonstick frying pan has three layers of PFOA-free non-stick coating, which allows you to prepare food with ease!

The OXO Good Grips nonstick pans are oven-safe as they can endure a 430°F temperature like a true champion!

best non stick pan material

What is better nonstick or ceramic?

Both ceramic and nonstick pans have their pros and cons, so let's examine some of them.

When it comes to ceramic pans, it's relatively affordable them some of the stainless steel cookware but expensive than Teflon pans. Where ceramic cookware surface has more advantage because the cooking surface retains more heat, so it's quicker to cook your favorite meals at a higher temperature.

Non-stick coating pans are relatively affordable but not so durable. The Teflon can chip and wear off over time. However, they are super easy to maintain and clean after every use. They heat up quickly but do not retain heat better than ceramic.

Ultimately, you would have to choose between these two types based on your cooking skills and desires.

What can you not cook in a non-stick pan?

Although non-stick pans have their advantages, there are stills some foods you have to be careful around. For example, you can't cook acidic foods or tomatoes as they will wear off the coating.

However, you can search for pans made out of anodized aluminum, which allows you to cook with these foods. Our favorite pan in this category is the Cuisinart 622-30G Chef's Classic Nonstick.

Should you preheat non-stick pans?

best non stick pan set

You should not preheat an empty pan, especially those made out of aluminum.

Aluminum non-stick pans heat up faster than those made out of stainless steel, so there is no need to preheat them before cooking. The only method you should do is add a splash of oil and wait for only a few seconds for it to heat. Nothing more than that.

Final Words

We have listed and reviewed everything you need to know about the best non-stick pan America's Test Kitchen! I bet your choice is a whole lot easier now that you have a clear picture of what you need to be looking for in the best nonstick pans!

The winner would have to be the incredible Carote 8 Inch Nonstick Skillet Pan when it comes to our top pick. It's an outstanding fry pan everyone needs in their cookware collection.

CAROTE Nonstick Frying Pan Skillet,Non Stick Granite Fry Pan Egg Pan Omelet Pans, Stone Cookware...*
  • Eco-friendly Classic Granite – Non-stick Granite Material, PFOS,PFOA free, our cookware ensures your daily cooking is always safer and healthier.
  • Easy To Clean – Just wipe it with a paper towel or rinse it with water, Less Co2 emission and Less water wasted.
  • Suitable For All Stoves – Heats up quickly and evenly with extended bottom design. High magnetic conductive stainless steel base allows our nonstick cookware to work on all cooktops, including...
  • Less Oil Needed & Less Smoke Released: Our non-stick frying pan can be used for any cooking needs like egg pan,omelette pan, or grill pan with less oil. Reduce unnecessary fat intake, and stay away...
  • Service & Guarantee – Each CAROTE cookware passes strict multi inspection process.In case you received defect items caused by delivery, please don't hesitate to reach out, thanks. You will be...

Leave a Comment