The Best Propane Smoker – Excellent Choice for the BBQ in 2019

Are you in need of a propane smoker to spice up your BBQ parties and outdoor gatherings? Check out our article here to see the best propane smoker you can get in 2019!

If you have done your homework on how to host the most memorable BBQ parties, you may probably know the right answer. It is to invest in the best propane smoker!

Unlike a charcoal grill - which can leave ash everywhere and only accommodate a few cooking methods - a propane smoker is capable of roasting the juiciest meat. Also, let’s not forget that a propane smoker is usually easier to use, more affordable for most customers, and can get the cooking tasks done in no time.

Are the previous advantages enough to convince you of buying the best propane smoker? If yes, keep scrolling down and see our recommendations on the smokers that fit your needs!


A Review of the 7 Best Propane Smokers You Can Get in 2019

Editor's Choices
PIT BOSS 77435 Vertical Lp Gas Smoker, Red*
Cuisinart COS-244 Vertical 36" Propane Smoker, Black*
Best Selling
Dyna-Glo DGY784BDP 36" Vertical LP Gas Smoker*
Customer Rating's
Best feature
Compact and attractive design
High efficiency
Editor's Choices
PIT BOSS 77435 Vertical Lp Gas Smoker, Red*
Customer Rating's
Best feature
Compact and attractive design
Cuisinart COS-244 Vertical 36" Propane Smoker, Black*
Customer Rating's
Best feature
Best Selling
Dyna-Glo DGY784BDP 36" Vertical LP Gas Smoker*
Customer Rating's
Best feature
High efficiency
Pit Boss Grills 77435 – Best Among Attractive Smokers

The first item in our review of the best propane smokers is model 77435 from Pit Boss Grills. If you need a high-end and fashionable smoker, then you mustn’t miss out on this product.

The first thing we noticed about this smoker is its compact and attractive design. Built to satisfy the basic grilling needs of a 4-people meal, Pit Boss Grills 77435 features a space-saving cooking area, yet still large enough to roast ribs, chicken, and turkey. And that is not to mention its crimson coat!

Inside this machine are three porcelain-enameled, adjustable grilling grates, accompanied by a powder-coated chip tray. Together, they create a sturdy construction that allows users to enjoy the smoker for at least a few years.

To ensure a pleasant cooking experience for customers, Pit Boss Grills 77435 has integrated a large viewing window. Now, you no longer have to open the door from time to time whenever you need to check on your food.

However, do not forget that this machine is not highly portable. It can be extremely heavy to move around, so make sure you do not hurt yourself while trying to transport Pit Boss Grills 77435 from one place to another.

Apart from that disadvantage, Pit Boss Grills 77435 is still very much a worthwhile purchase. It might not be very economical for most people, but it works like magic! What not to like?

  • Porcelain-enameled grilling grates.
  • Easy-to-pull-out wood chip tray.
  • Difficult to reach low temperatures.

Cuisinart COS-244 Vertical 36" Propane Smoker – Best for Both Amateur and Professional Cooks

If you usually struggle with operating a propane smoker, then you will love Cuisinart COS-244. Easily set up and used, this smoker from Cuisinart is the perfect choice for a hassle-free outdoor gathering or any professional chef as well.

Cuisinart COS-244 Vertical 36" Propane Smoker has a spacious cooking area, divided by four removable grilling grates. You can put a whole turkey, ribs or mushrooms into the smoker, and you can even bake pies here! How versatile!

Another reason why you should try out this lovely smoker is because of its compactness with a 40-inch hose and a regulator that will be easily attached to a standard propane tank. One of the advantages of this smoker is the fact that you can control the oven the amount of smoke in the oven and the temperature.

Still, its versatility on the side, this smoker has two main disadvantages. First is that you have to open the door to load more wood chips and the second is the fact that you can't just set it at a temperature and leave it - you have to monitor it.

Besides these minor drawbacks, we would say that Cuisinart COS-244 is worth a try.

  • Cooking recipes included in the purchase.
  • Durable.
  • Stainless steel racks
  • A porcelain enameled steel tray
  • You have to monitor the temperature
  • You need to open the door to load more wood

Dyna-Glo DGY784BDP – Best High-Efficient Smoker

Next on our list of the best propane smokers is model DGY784BDP from Dyna-Glo.

Have you ever been in a situation where you really like a gas smoker, but it’s just too big or too small for your needs? With Dyna-Glo DGY784BDP, you will no longer have to worry about that.

Dyna-Glo allows you to choose the size for your smoke between three choices: standard, large, and extra-large. Also, with a small surcharge, you can get a nylon cover for your smoker, which offers better protection against external factors. Yay!

The reason why we highly recommend Dyna-Glo DGY784BDP is its high efficiency. With a spacious cooking space, Dyna-Glo does not limit you from having the juiciest loads of roasted meat.

Furthermore, Dyna-Glo DGY784BDP comes with four removable cooking grates at different heights. This makes sure the smoker can fit different cooking methods, from slow cook to roast. What’s not to like?

However, you probably would want to know that some Dyna-Glo accessories are not built to last. The handles attached to the chip box are easily breakable, which can be pretty annoying if you expect a sturdy smoker.

But still, if you do not mind buying some replacements now and then, we would say that Dyna-Glo DGY784BDP is the best head start for amateur cooks. It is affordable, it is highly functional, and it is easy to use!

  • Good heat control through the double door design and a temperature gauge.
  • Porcelain-enameled cover.
  • Too much smoke is released during cooking.
  • Difficult to clean up.

Masterbuilt 20050614 – Best For Professional Cooks

If you want a slightly bigger smoker than the Dyna-Glo but at the same efficiency level, why don’t you have a look at model 20050614 from Masterbuilt?

This product bears some similarities with the previously introduced smoker. It features four grilling grates at four different heights, which makes it easier for you to stuff in a lot of food with versatile cooking methods.

That is not to mention the dual 8250 BTU burners, with an easy-to-use push-button, so you can ignite the fire in no time. For better heat regulation, Masterbuilt has two built-in double doors to make sure the smoker is well ventilated.

But still, there are a couple of things we dislike about Masterbuilt 20050614. First of all, the attached thermometer and temperature regulator are not reliable. They tend to give incorrect figures all the time, so don’t bother checking them out. Not cool, right?

All in all, we believe that Masterbuilt 20050614 is a reasonable choice when it comes to the best propane smoker. However, due to some of its defective components, it is best that this product reserved for professional cooks.

  • Large cooking space.
  • A viewing window for a better checkup on food.
  • Faulty components.
  • Complicated assembly.

Smoke Hollow 44241G2 – Best for Large Parties

Now, in case you want a large capacity in a high-end smoker, then you must not miss out on modem 44241G2 from Smoke Hollow. Let’s explore its alluring features together!

The first thing we notice about Smoke Hollow 44241G2 is its seemingly endless cooking area. With up to 6.5 cubic feet, this smoker is enough for you if you have to feed up to 12 people at an outdoor party.

To make your cooking tasks easier, Smoke Hollow 44241G2 comes with - guess what - six different grilling grates! There are 2 standard grates, 2 jerky grids, 1 rib rack, and 1 sausage hanger. Now, let’s say goodbye to all the fuss when you have to put your food in carefully, lest them mix up with each other.

Since the smoker aims at cooking a huge amount of food, you will find two stainless steel burners at both ends of the control board. They operate independently of each other, so feel free to adjust them based on your needs.

But do not expect perfection from this product. Some customers have filed their complaints about the faulty temperature indicator, so basically you will have to buy a brand new thermometer if you want to know how hot your smoker is.

In short, if you are about to host a large gathering this weekend, opt for Smoke Hollow 44241G2 and see how it works in your favor!

  • A dual-door design to limit heat and smoke release.
  • Wide variety of grilling grates.
  • Slightly expensive for average customers.

Masterbuilt MB20051316 – Best Among Durable Smokers

If you are a fan of Masterbuilt, which is one of the leading manufacturers in the grilling industry, you will love its MB20051316 model. Today, let’s see what you can get from this product.

The most distinctive feature of this Masterbuilt propane smoker is its sturdiness. The whole machine is made from anti-rust stainless steel, with several components being coated with porcelain.

Furthermore, the cooking grates are from chrome, so expect to see your smoker last for a long time. Talking about a worthy investment in cookware!

That is not to mention the portability of this smoker. Unlike other heavy-duty smokers, Masterbuilt MB20051316 features four carrying wheels, so you can easily move your gadget around.

But be aware that this propane smoker is not perfect. Like most of its counterparts, Masterbuilt MB20051316 cannot get less than 250 degrees even though the dial button is turned all the way down.

However, this does not mean that Masterbuilt MB20051316 does not work well. If you need to feed a lot of people at a party, then Masterbuilt MB20051316 is your best bet!

  • Low maintenance required.
  • The heat is retained evenly.
  • Durable materials.
  • No internal thermometer.

Char-Broil 12701705P1 – The Smoker with Excellent Heat Control

Char-Broil is among the most popular grilling brands, and we believe its liquid propane gas smoker deserves a place on our list today. Stay tuned to see what this smoker has to offer!

What strikes us first about Char-Broil smoker is its sturdy design. The outer coat is made from anti-rust stainless steel, coupled with the chrome-plated grilling grates. Together, they create a durable gadget that promises to live past a few summers of BBQ parties.

And let’s not forget about the high capacity of Char-Broil smoker. With up to 7566 cubic inches inside, this product is your quickest solution to feed at least 5 people.

However, what is truly outstanding about Char-Broil propane smoker is its design. There is a dual drawer, which enables users to add and remove wood chips and water during the cooking process. Also, you can have total control over how hot the smoker is through the use of a temperature dial. Doesn’t it sound fun?

Yet, there is one thing you may not like about this smoker. Most customers report about errors during shipment, which results in cosmetic damages.

But if you are fine with some cracks on the surface of the smoker, then Char-Broil propane smoker is good to go for you!

  • Excellent heat control.
  • Large cooking area.
  • Porcelain-enameled water pan.
  • Inconsistent wields.

How to Get the Best Propane Smoker?

1. Cooking Space

The cooking section is where your attention should steer at first. If you are about to host a family party, the chances are you only need a smoker with a small cooking area.

However, in case we are talking about a big outdoor get-together with more than five people, you should invest in a smoker with a big cooking space.

2. Overall Size and Portability

best propane smoker grill

The cooking space of a smoker is usually linked to its overall size. Similarly to what we said before, go for a small-size smoker if you do not need to feed a lot of people, and vice versa.

Another factor that is usually overlooked is propane smoker’s portability. Does the smoker has attached wheels, so you can easily transport it? Or you have to push the smoker using a bar handle? Either way, make sure that your smoker can be maneuvered without much difficulty, because trust us, you would not like to move a heavy-duty smoker around manually!

3. Price Range

The affordability of a smoker has a significant impact on your final choice when going shopping, so be careful.

Most propane smokers on the market usually cost more than $250, which can be a bit of a stretch for most middle-class customers. Some high-end, large-capacity propane smokers can even go up to the price range of more than $400!

However, you do not need to buy the most expensive product on the market, because it won't be a guarantee that it will fit your needs. Unless you are running a restaurant with a focus on BBQ cuisines, other medium-range propane smokers will be enough to satisfy your cooking needs. And they will not dry your wallet also!

4. Warranty

A propane smoker needs to be handled with care, so it can last a few summers of BBQ parties. While the users must take this machine’s maintenance into our hands, do not forget that you can seek assistance and support from the manufacturers.

Most propane smokers come with a two-year warranty, which promises to fix any errors on your cookware. Some other companies even offer lifetime insurance, but those are rare in number.

Either way, remember to study the warranty policies of a propane smoker before buying it to make sure it is worth your money.

5. Cleanup

best propane smokers consumer reports

After a BBQ party is over, what worries you the most is probably the cleanup.

Some propane smokers come with a removable ashtray, so you can quickly empty the gasket and tidy the whole thing without much trouble.

Yet, there are other propane smokers that require manual cleanup.

Another factor is the used grates. Sometimes, food may get stuck on the grates, causing an unpleasant scene and a cleanup challenge. We suggest that you season the grates with oil or butter beforehand, so the meat is less likely to be sticky.

6. Availability

There are chances that a component inside your propane smoker breaks down, or decrease in quality after being used for a long time.

The solution here is to get a replacement. But not all grilling accessories are universally accessible. Hence, before you decide to buy a propane smoker, it is always worth to research on the availability of relevant grilling gears.

Final Thought

Getting the best propane smoker is not an easy task, but with our review, we hope that you are clear on which product to pick up.

However, if you want our final piece of advice, we would say that Pit Boss Grills smoker is the ideal propane smoker for all outdoor gatherings. It provides customers with an easy-to-use setting, a spacious cooking area, and an ideal solution to have the most mouth-watering BBQs.

PIT BOSS 77435 Vertical Lp Gas Smoker, Red*
  • Dual valve/dual burner system provides 100-350 temperature range
  • Three porcelain coated cooking grids, 800 sq in
  • Stainless Steel burners - 12, 500 BTU total
  • External access to wood chip drawer and grease tray
  • Large viewing window with high temperature door seal

Do you find our article helpful? Then let’s share it around with your friends and families. They might need a propane smoker for a BBQ party as well!

You may also like

Leave a Comment