Healthy and Tasty: The Best Air Fryer Toaster Oven Consumer Reports 2022

Among the billion advantages we encounter daily, technological advancement has brought a present for world-class gourmets as well.

Healthy yet delicious meals, a dream of every food hedonist, are no more an illusion thanks to high-end air fryers.

The rumor has it that not a single person who tried hot air frying has ever returned to the good old-fashioned oil cooking.

And I cannot but ask, are they really that good?

What better way to check it than in the sole biggest collection of Consumer Reports, with honest, first-hand experiences, comments, and advice.

Today we explored what the best air fryer toaster ovens have to offer, what their flaws might be, and with the help of honest customers, we crowned the absolutely best air fryer toaster oven.

Stay tuned!

More...

Top 3 Recommendations

Top 8 Reviews of the Best Air Fryer Toaster Ovens

COSORI CO130-AO Air Fryer Toaster Combo - Top Pick

A synonym for endless possibilities, Cosori CO130-AO is one of the best sellers in the air fryer industry.

Well-built, easy to use, intuitive, and large, this oven/air fryer/toaster/ anything-you-want-it-to-be makes every family dinner or home party a feast to remember.

Although a budget-friendly option, this device features smart technology and high-grade materials; hence it's built to last and provide flawless service and fantastic results.

To start from the exterior, the entire device is made of stainless steel, available in silver and black variants.

It also includes a large LE display and two control knobs, so it's incredibly intuitive to set everything up and cook like a professional chef.

The fryer comes with twelve preset programs, six accessories, and a cookbook, so it's pretty straightforward to use it for all kinds of different meals.

Due to 360 degrees rapid heat circulation, five smart heating elements, and a fan with two speeds, you can really be creative.

You can also use it as a practical food dehydrator to make the crispiest beef jerky in the neighborhood or bake the softest cookies.

It's all the same oven, but with different settings.

As I mentioned, one of the advantages this fryer offers is its large capacity.

Namely, a 30L oven can fit a 13-inch pizza, six slices of toast, or an entire chicken.

And since you get a food tray, a wire rack, a fried basket, a crumb tray, a rotisserie fork set, and a rotisserie handle, handling an entire chicken or a large pizza won't be a problem.

When it comes to fine details that make this device the best air fryer, it has an integrated oven light and heat-protected glass door, so it's easy to watch your air-fried meals and make sure they are not overcooked.

Pros
  • Six accessories
  • Large oven
  • Twelve preset programs
  • Interior oven light
  • Non-stick interior
  • Crumb Tray
Cons
  • The glass door gets really hot

Pro Breeze 12.7 Quart Air Fryer Oven - Runner Up

Here we have one elegant air fryer toaster oven that's incredibly functional and intuitive to use.

In addition to this, the oven is simple to clean and very practical; therefore, it's not a surprise that it has four thousand customer ratings, of which 73% are five stars.

Pro Breeze creates market-leading products which years ago won the trust of customers.

Nowadays, they strive to innovate and live up to the old fame, constantly improving and advancing.

When it comes to this air fryer oven toaster, it's a smaller model, with excellent capacity and a reasonable price, affordable to anyone.

Actually, it's the second cheapest model on this list, but regardless it offers the same quality and performance as the other products.

It's a 1800 Watt powerful fryer with the capacity of 12 quarts and twelve different built-in programs that offer versatility and flexibility in cooking.

And since it measures only 14 x 12 x 15 inches, it perfectly goes with your other kitchen appliances as it takes up very little space.

You can use it for cooking, frying, dehydrating, and many more since it comes with nineteen accessories.

This is the highest number of accessories provided with any model that we have reviewed by now.

It includes one drip tray, three baking trays, one rotisserie set, one rotating fry basket, and one fetch tool.

Furthermore, the rotisserie set includes skewers, forks, and fetching tools, providing all the instruments you need for a juicy, crispy chicken.

With a digital LED display, the setup is a piece of cake, and since it has an internal light, you can watch the food and make sure it's not overcooked.

Importantly, the air fryer toaster oven is tested for safety; hence you won't have to worry about any unpredictable situations.

Pros
  • Affordable
  • Elegant
  • High-quality
  • Compact
  • 19 accessories
Cons
  • Slow cook

Instant Vortex Plus 10 Quart Air Fryer - Budget Pick

Cook dinner in half the usual time. Sounds interesting?

Well, that's what Instant Vortex Plus air fryer oven has to offer.

It's a multifunctional device with many accessories, built to provide that deep-fried taste without any oil, and much faster than your old oven.

The smart oven air fryer has an extra-large capacity, meaning you can cook the whole chicken, nine slices of toast, or a small cake inside.

And given the flexible temperature settings, seven cooking functions, and adjustable thermostat, whatever you decide to make, the cooking settings can be adjusted for that meal precisely.

This fryer toaster oven features a silver-black design, with a stainless-steel exterior and a sleek surface that's super-easy to clean.

What is more, all the trays and accessories are dishwasher safe, so you can throw them into your dishwasher and save some extra time and effort on washing.

What differentiates this air fryer from a convection toaster oven is the hot air that circulates around the food, creating the air roast on the outside, while all the moisture stays trapped inside, resulting in healthy meals that are just as delicious as the fried foods.

This specific effect is achieved thanks to the EvenCrisp Technology TM.

Besides the mentioned function, this air fryer toaster oven has built-in programs for toast, air broil, dehydrate, and rotisserie.

Everything is effortless to adjust on the bright, bold screen with fourteen touch controls.

When it comes to the accessories, it includes two perforated pans, one drip tray, one rotisserie basket, two rotisserie forks, one spit, and one lift.

Besides all mentioned above, the air fryer toaster oven is safe to use since it includes Overheat Protection.

Pros
  • Extra-large
  • Safe
  • Adjustable
  • Intuitive
  • Easy to wash
  • Many accessories
Cons
  • Toxic smell

Ninja DT251 Foodi 10-in-1 Smart XL Air Fry Oven - The Most Intuitive

If the seven-in-one design of the Instant Vortex air fryer amazed you, hold your breath for the innovative Ninja Foodi Digital Fry air fryer toaster oven.

It's smart, intuitive, stylish, and practical, ideal for a smaller family with a passion for cooking and an inclination towards a healthy lifestyle.

If there's one thing that describes Ninja kitchen appliances the best, it's advancement.

They constantly change and develop to meet the latest industrial standards and make their appliances as user-friendly as possible.

First of all, this 1800W powerful Ninja Foodi Digital Fry air fryer toaster oven has ten built-in programs that allow you to Air Fry, Air Roast, Whole Roast, Bake, Broil, Toast, Bagel, Dehydrate, Reheat, and Make Perfect Pizza.

Compare this to traditional toaster ovens, and you get a clear picture of the technological advancement that we spoke about in the beginning.

You can adjust the cooking temperature, and thanks to the Foodi Smart Thermometer, with a single click of a button, you can preset the doneness level and get just the email you wanted.

The air fry feature provides ten times crispier results than the conventional oven thanks to the even air ventilation system and a third heat source, rear-placed to distribute the heat evenly without the need for tray rotation.

What is more, the high-velocity fan provides airflow up to 130CFMs for best results.

Additionally, this fryer toaster oven features a sleek stainless steel design with a clear, intuitive display for easy operation.

And it includes seven accessories, enabling even two-level cooking since it has enough space for a 5 -lb chicken and a small, 12-inch pizza at once.

All in all, this is one highly advanced fryer toaster oven with smart technology and a user-friendly system, built to surpass the convection bake and provide the topmost healthy meals with minimal effort.

Pros
  • Ten-in-one system
  • High-velocity fan
  • Seven accessories
  • Easy-to-use
  • Two-level even cooking
Cons
  • A few defective products delivered

Cuisinart TOA-60 Convection Toaster Oven Airfryer - The Most Popular

Here we have one industrial, modern convection oven toaster from Cuisinart, one of the customers' favorites and most certainly the best air fryer toaster for the price.

It's almost suspicious how affordable this appliance is, given its fantastic specifications and countless positive customer ratings. Yet the fryer exhibits fantastic quality, so apparently, Cuisinart tries to keep its prices affordable for everyone.

This is a 1800W powerful device, with seven preset functions, for frying, convection baking, convection broiling, baking, broiling, warming, and toasting.

On the outside, this air fryer toaster oven incorporates a silver stainless steel exterior.

At the same time, the inside is a non-stick surface, easy to clean, and heat-resistant. 

Therefore, you can place the appliance wherever you want; it won't be a potential hazard to the surroundings.

Convection heating distributes temperature evenly, making sure both levels are equally treated, hence eliminating the need for tray replacement and switching.

The air fryer also has an interior light and a button on the outside that controls it, so you can turn it on or off as you wish.

However, it doesn't have a digital display, but four knobs, each regulating one specific function: one for temperature, one for timer, one for function settings, and one for toast.

Moreover, the capacity of the oven is excellent; you can roast a 4lbs chicken or air fry three pounds of chicken wings.

There is enough space for six slices of toast or a 12-inch pizza.

When it comes to the accessories, the air fryer comes with an oven rack, a baking pan, and one air fryer basket.

Pros
  • Simple
  • Large capacity
  • Seven functions
  • Cooking trays included
Cons
  • No digital display

Ninja DT201 Foodi 10-in-1 XL Pro Air Fry Digital - The Most Functions

Iconites brings another fantastic budget-friendly air fryer to our list.

It includes smart technology with ten functions, a huge LED screen, and easy-to-use touch buttons.

Although it looks quite compact, this air fryer toaster oven has an extra-large capacity of 18.93 liters.

This 1800W powerful air fryer has a 360-degree air circulation with accelerated airflow for 25-30% faster cooking and better results.

It's an air fryer, a rotisserie oven, a microwave oven, a thawing box, a toaster, and a dehydrator, all in one.

Depending on the function you're using, you can cook on one or more levels, and one specific feature that makes this air dehydrator superior to other models on the market is thirteen different accessories.

With these additions, you can customize your appliance to your needs and cook the food just the way you want.

It comes with two kitchen gloves, one fetch rack, one drip tray, one rotating basket for french fries, one rotisserie basket, one chicken fork, one mesh basket, and five airflow racks.

One facilitating characteristic of the accessories is that all of them are dishwasher-safe; hence it's a piece of cake to wash them and keep the oven clean at all times.

Besides different cooking settings, you can adjust the temperature range.

It goes from 180℉ to 400℉, and due to its innovative design, the food is roasted on the outside, while the moisture stays trapped inside, adding more flavor and deliciousness to your meal.

Pros
  • large capacity
  • Affordable
  • Innovative design
  • Thirteen accessories
  • Dishwasher-safe accessories
Cons
  • Not as high-quality as advertised

Calphalon Performance Air Fry Convection Oven - Smart Oven Air Fryer

Here we have an excellent air fryer from Calphalon, a mid-range price-wise yet exceptional in every aspect performance-wise.

What makes this device different from convection toaster ovens is the advanced technology with upgraded performance that provides an even heat distribution, resulting in healthy, delicious meals.

Calphalon Air Fryer includes eleven cooking presets, including air frying, baking, roasting, broiling dehydration, etc.

These settings enable you to cook various meals from french fries to chicken and deserts with a 100% success rate.

This air fryer includes a Quartz Heat technology that's designed to circulate hot air 40% more evenly than standard fryers; thus, you can cook food faster without compromising the softness and moisture.

It traps the moisture inside, so even if the chicken is evenly cooked without being dry and tasteless, all the flavors stay inside.

When you want to cook food in no time, you can use turbo convection that increases air circulation, frying the food quickly with the same results.

It's incredibly intuitive to set everything up due to the high-contrast LCD with all the settings displayed, three control buttons, and two knobs for fine settings.

This superior air fryer toaster oven is made of high-grade black steel with a stainless steel finish, while the interior includes a non-stick surface for effortless cleaning.

From the accessories, you get an air fry basket, a baking pan, a wire rack, and a removable crumb tray.

Pros
  • Advanced technology
  • Turbo convection
  • Even heat distribution
  • Faster cooking
  • Intuitive LCD
Cons
  • Toaster function needs improvement

Geek Chef Air Fryer Toaster Oven - Large capacity

Here we have another silver stainless steel beauty with a multifunctional design and the latest air frying technology integrated.

It's also on the affordable end of the market, ready to prove it's worth every penny

Don't let the low cost deceive you, though; with two thousand ratings and an average of 4.5 stars, this air fryer toaster oven is evidently worth it.

Since Geek Chef is not the most popular brand on Amazon, I'd first like to mention the features that prove the reliability of this product.

Namely, this air fryer is ETL-listed for safety, offering overheat protection and completely safe functioning.

Its smart design includes seven functions, easily controlled by four simple knobs, one controlling the temperature, the next timer settings, one for cooking settings, and one for toasting.

The cooking functions include a convection oven, microwave heater, air fryer, convection toaster, thaw box, and dehydrator.

The oven has an extra-large capacity, measured to provide enough space for a 10-people feast.

And it works on up to three levels; hence you can cook multiple meals at once, making the entire cooking process faster and more practical.

It comes with four accessories, a cooking pan, an air fryer basket, a drip tray, and an oven rack.

With so many options and smartly placed heating elements, you'll get perfectly crispy yet delicious food every time.

On top of everything, the Geek Chef offers a thirty-day money-back guarantee, a one-year warranty, and lifetime technical support.

Besides all these fantastic features, this air fryer is one of the cheapest solutions on the market, showing extraordinary quality per price.

Pros
  • Multi-functionality
  • Stainless steel
  • Warranty
  • Guarantee
  • Technical support
  • Simple knob control
Cons
  • It could be more advanced

Buyer's Guide

Not all air fryer toaster ovens are the same, especially because these devices are multifunctional, combining many different features; hence they need a flawless design for good functioning.

Still, there are a few features that you should pay special attention to in order to minimize the chances of a faulty device.

From the counter space to air velocity, here are the features you need to take into consideration before you spend any money on an air fryer toaster oven.

1. Size

best air fryer toaster oven consumer reports 2022

This is probably the most logical thing to consider. Before you buy anything, check if you have a space for it.

In this particular case, measure the counter space, and compare it with the size of the air fryer toaster oven to make sure it fits with the rest of your kitchen appliances.


2. Material

The feature that in 99% predetermines the quality and durability of any product is the material it is built of.

In this case, the best material for the exterior is stainless steel.

Not just that it gives your fryer a sleek, shiny look, but it also has excellent properties, being rust-resistant and easy to clean.

On the other hand, the interior should include a non-stick surface that's also easy to clean and heat-resistant so that the vapors don't stay on the walls causing unpleasant smells and hard-to-clean stains.

Additionally, if your air fryer toaster has a glass door, check if the door is heat resistant and if the handle remains cold during frying.

Because many times, the glass gets super-hot, and if the heat is transferred to the handle, it won't be possible to open the door conveniently.


3. Functions

best large air fryer toaster oven consumer reports

The main reason why people buy air fryer toaster ovens is the air frying.

It's a healthy way to deep fry food without excess oil and fats that stick to your hips and cause health issues.

However, this is not the only function your air fryer toaster oven should have.

Most of them can be used for convection broil, convection bake, dehydration, rotisserie, toasting, reheating, etc.

The more functions it has, the more versatile meals you can make.

However, make sure the cooking cycle in the instructions is backed up with appropriate settings.


4. The Capacity

Besides the size of the air fryers themselves, the size of the basket and the baking oven matter.

Most air fryer toaster ovens can fit a 5lbs chicken or nine slices of bread, which is great.

Most oven pans should be able to fit a 12-inch pizza, while the basket should fit a bag of fried foods at once.

So these are the standards you should measure your air fryer by.


5. The Accessories

The accessories are of integral importance as well, since they predetermine what you will be able to do with the air fryer.

A good oven air fryer has oven racks, a baking tray, an air fry basket, a rotisserie set, and perforated trays.

Everything else is a nice addition, but these are the basics.


6. Airflow

best air fryer toaster ovens consumer reports

Air frying entirely relies on air circulation.

To enable even frying and desired results, the fan should be top-placed so that the hot air circles around the food, resulting in even results.

Also, the higher the air velocity, the faster your meal will be done.

Also, the best air fryer has the dehydration function, so the air velocity will also affect the speed and the performance of the dehydration.


7. Temperature Range

The best air fryer toaster has more than one heat source.

When there are more heat sources, manufacturers place them in different directions; hence the heat is distributed evenly, and the result is delicious food, crispy on the outside and juicy on the inside.


8. Display

One not so crucial yet important feature is the display.

Some people like simple settings, for example, knobs and buttons.

Yet, the newer generations of devices have LED or LCD screens that have touch buttons and allow easy adjustments.

I prefer kitchen appliances with large LED screens because they are incredibly intuitive, and everything is shown on the screen.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the greatest air fryer oven, according to Consumer Reports?

According to the latest Consumer Reports, the best air fryer oven/convection oven is the Cuisinart Convection Toaster Oven.


What is the best air fryer toaster oven combo?

To my mind, the COSORI CO130-AO Air Fryer Combo is the best air fryer/oven combo, as it exhibits fantastic characteristics and excellent performance, also more options than the Cuisinart Air Fryer Toaster.


Which is better, air fryers or air fryer toaster ovens?

Air fryer's toaster oven definitely provides more versatility in cooking and upgraded functions since it's both a convection oven and an air fryer.


Is it worth buying a high-end air fryer toaster oven?

best air fryer toaster oven rotisserie consumer reports

According to customer reviews and my own experience, it is. You make the food quickly, without any mess, and it's healthier.

With many cooking functions, you can slow cook, dehydrate or fry food, and all that without any oil.

So it definitely is worth it in the long run.


How does an air fryer toaster oven work?

The air fryer toaster oven has one or more heat sources and a fan.

The fan circulates hot air around your food, making it crispy on the outside while keeping all the juices inside the food.

It doesn't need any oil, so it's perfectly healthy.

Final Thoughts

I hope you understood our short saga about the air fryers.

If this article inspired you to replace your old convection toaster for the best air fryer toaster oven, consumer reports-based, I'd like to mention again our top pick - the COSORI CO130-AO Air Fryer Toaster Combo.

It's affordable, highly adjustable, including innovative technology and many warm functions.

COSORI Air Fryer Toaster Oven Combo, 12-in-1, Countertop ConvectionOven 32QT XL Large Capacity,...*
  • CONVECTION FUNCTION: Reduce your cooking time by using the Smart Air Fryer Toaster Oven. Use the convection fan for fast and even cooking—especially if you like crispy results. This function is...
  • LESS OIL: Air fry your food with up to 85% less oil than traditional deep-fried foods, making for a simpler cooking experience
  • 12 FUNCTIONS: Choose the preset that’s best for you without needing to set a temperature. Pick from Toast, Bagel, Pizza, Bake, Roast, Air Fry, Broil, Cookies, Rotisserie, Dehydrate, Ferment, or...
  • LARGE CAPACITY: Cook for 5-7 people with the 32-quart/30-litre air fryer toaster oven, which can fit a 13-inch pizza, 6 slices of bread, or an entire rotisserie chicken
  • RECIPES & ACCESSORIES: Check out the included 100 recipe book and accessories such as the crumb tray, fry basket, food tray, wire rack, and rotisserie fork set for more cooking options. To purchase a...

You may also like

Leave a Comment